Join Hall of Fame baseball writer Rick Hummel for his live Cardinals chat at 11 a.m. Monday
Bring your Cards questions and comments to Monday’s 11 a.m. live chat.
3rd & 7 37yd
3rd & 7 37yd
B
S
O
close
close

-





-
-
-
-
-
-
I know Hicks as a starter was billed as "always the plan" but had Reyes and especially Jack not gotten hurt would we really be seeing Hicks in AAA (and might when Jack returns) and staying there until there is a free spot? Or was the plan more likely that they wanted Hicks as a multi inning high leverage reliever (or opener)?
-
-
I need to vent. I have heard from a very trusted source that a certain coach, who will remain nameless, who's focus is on offense is now claiming the lackluster offensive results are due to the stadium the cards play their home games in. It's past time for this coach to be sent packing, in my opinion.
Now for my questions. Why is it scored a sac fly when a batter hits a fly ball to score a run, but not so when a batter hits a deep fly that allows runners to advance from 2nd to 3rd? And, when is a wild pitch scored a wild pitch? I seem to recall the playoff series years ago when Ankiel had his struggles, many of his pitches went to the backstop, but only those where runners scored we scored as wild pitches.
Thanks for all you do! -
To answer the "sac fly" question, there was a day when players would consciously try to hit a fly ball with a runner at third and under two out. Now they're trying to hit a fly ball all the time. I don't think there should be such a thing as a sacrifice fly. It would still be an RBI but it would be a time at-bat. Wild pitches are charged when it is determined by the scorer that the catcher couldn't make a play. Ankiel was charged with many wild pitches whether runs scored or not on the errant tosses. .
-
-
-
-
-
-
It's my understanding they will no longer play a one game playoff to determine division winners in event of a tie at seasons end. If this is so then you can throw out the unwritten rule and push to score as much as possible regardless of score in regular season games. Can you clear this up?
-
-
-
-
I appreciate that you have been around the game a long time, and you have seen many things change during the course of the season. A player starts off strong then finishes poorly or vise versa. In many ways you seem to mirror the Cardinals front office. I understand there is a value to being patient, but there is also a time to value urgency. If Dejong doesn’t rebound what does the team do? There aren’t good internal options. Fans have heard the song and dance about the player cost being too high for trades during the season. There were many options in the off season. Making knee jerk reactions is foolish, but always saying give it more time doesn’t make you wise.
-
If DeJong doesn't rebound, then Sosa will get a chance. Failing that, the Cardinals might have to deal for somebody or make Edman a shortstop. The off-season is over. The Cardinals didn't pursue a shortstop. You can take whatever stance you want concerning that but it's too late to lament that. Everyone moves on.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
The Atlanta Braves were 5th in overall defense in the National League, Houston was #1, yet the Braves are the reigning champs. I understand defense is important but isn't it better to have a good balance of defense and offense? You can be the best defensive team in the league but if you're not hitting....
-
-
That Reggie Smith for Joe Ferguson trade was a bad one. Been trying to forget that for almost 50 years. If I recall right, Hernandez came up at the same time. Some of those 70s teams with Hernandez. Simmons, and later, Templeton were fun, even if they did not win and divisions. I recall opening day (1979 or 1980) with Vukovich pitching. Thought he would do well, but we traded him the next year. And Pete Falcone always was potential unreached. Baseball can be fun even in years we don't win the World Series.
-
-
-
Why can't Marmol just tell Goldy or Edman 'you are getting a day off this week (week of 5/1) but will decide which day based on matchups. That makes more sense from a baseball point. Like it was said earlier....Goldy had a history of hitting yesterday's pitcher well, but Marmol sat him. That is Marmol's only big blunder I feel as manager so far. Give them days off but base it on matchups...not a day set in stone!
-
There's no external shortstop slash shortstop available because Moe refused to wade into the Waters of the best free agent shortstop class in a long time because he went to push DeJong. And you keep saying 3 weeks. We know what DeJong is, 3 years tells us we don't need more time. And quit deflecting criticism about DeJong by pointing out others aren't hitting. Weak