Join columnist Ben Frederickson for a live STL sports chat at 11 a.m. Tuesday
Ben Frederickson answers your Cardinals, Blues, St. Louis City, Mizzou and SLU questions in Tuesday's 11 a.m. live chat.
3rd & 7 37yd
3rd & 7 37yd
B
S
O
close
close

-





-
I'd like to see Burden get that job, but he has to catch the ball. With how limited practices and camp sessions are these days, you don't know what you don't know, but pregame evidence has suggested Burden catching punts is not a guarantee. He let a lot drop in high school and then caught them off the bounce with a full head of steam. That works in high school, not so well in college.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
The pitch clock can't get here fast enough. I've observed it in the minors. You hardly notice, but the game moves much quicker. Players will adjust. If they can't they weren't going to be players for long.I don't like the shift bans. I don't like putting a dam up where I think hitters can -- and some already are -- adjusting their offense to weaken the impact of the shifts. I think if the league didn't intervene more guys would adjust. I also wonder/worry about unintended consequences. The information defenses have is not going away. How will players be limited from leaning or drifting toward more advantageous positions during an-bat, which could cause distraction. How is that going to be enforced? The good news for the Cardinals is it should not affect them much. They have good athleticism on defense and are not one of the league's most shift-crazy teams, though they have used it more effectively under Shildt and now Marmol.
-
People keep asking if Carlson is a better version of Piscotty. His defense is probably better but Piscotty had 3 seasons of an OPS over .800 in his first 4 seasons, Carlson hasn't had one. I get it he's young and expectations are he'll improve but at some point he's in the majors and should be compared to other players at his position and not other players at his age which there are just a handful.
-
-
-
-
-
A lot can happen in a 21-game span. A lot. Cardinals have been less predictable than usual this season, under Marmol. They have used Jordan Hicks as a starter and an opener. They're brining back Steven Matz as a reliever. He's refreshed the bullpen on the fly with internal options now holding pretty important spots. I think they want to evaluate what things look like here down the final stretch before locking anything in. I don't think they're just saying that either.
-
-
-
-
Candace Buckner. It was a fun read. Of all the things I don't understand in sports, one of the biggest is paying for a ticket, paying for parking, paying for up-charged food and drink . . . and then leaving before it's over -- if there's something that could be coming that you could want to see. If the kids are hot and sweaty and you're good with missing whatever happens, all good. If you could wind up regretting it, best to stay in that seat.
-
With Kyrou’s contract done, the Blues are likely to have about $16M in cap space after the season (barring any trades of anyone under contract next season and assuming the cap goes up by $1M like it did this year). The Blues need six more forwards and a goalie signed for ‘23-24. Under those constraints, do you have any thoughts on the likelihood that a deal gets done with O’Reilly and if so any guess on where his salary comes in?
-
The pattern with the Blues that has become clear in recent seasons is that if a player gets very far into the final season of his contract without an extension, chances are he won't be coming back. Schenn, Parayko, Faulk, Thomas and now Kyrou all got early extensions. Pending unrestricted free agents have trended the other way: Pietrangelo, Schwartz, and most lately Perron. Scandella was an exception. So, a telling pattern will now have to be reversed for the captain to be extended. And it should be reversed. The Blues are signaling their future is Thomas and Kyrou, and that's great, but if you don't think these two young rising players could still learn from O'Reilly as captain, your fooling yourself. Especially now that Perron is gone. Tarasenko is not that guy, even if he plays well. And he's a free agent after this upcoming season, too.
-
-
The big version of that question could go down as one of the biggest STL sports what-ifs of all time. Would the Cardinals have a more recent World Series championship than 2011? Would Adam Wainwright and Yadier Molina both be Cardinals? Would Pujols have been a better version of himself than what the Angels got -- or would it have been the same here, where a bloated contract harmed the team? All kinds of rabbit holes to go down. I imagine the Cardinals would have a more recent World Series if he stayed, but my guess is he would have retired by now if his struggles here were as bad as they got in California, in part because he would not have wanted to let that play out here on this stage. What remains the coolest thing about this story, for St. Louis, is that it will be able to see Pujols start and end here -- while also saying it never once witnessed a bad Pujols season.
-
You think missing 697 was bad? My wife and I had SRO tickets to Game 6 2011. We stood next to some Rangers fans. (Great fans by the way and the sign they brought got me on TV for the game as I was in the shot when the cameras panned to it.) But, I digress.
Cardinals fans -- CARDINALS FANS! -- walked by us in the 7th inning and congratulated the Rangers fans we were standing next to on their World Series win. I've always wondered what those "fans" were thinking as they drove down 70, 40, or 55 on their way home........ they were at arguably the greatest WS game of all time and left early...... -
-
-
He took snaps at wildcat in week one. He's taking direct handoffs and pitches on jets sweeps. And I wouldn't be surprised if we see him in the return game soon. He's being used in a multifaceted role now. He just needs to be sure to catch balls that hit him in the hands. He's had some freshman moments. Drinkwitz said today in CoMo that he wants Burden to get more touches but play fewer snaps. Maximizing his value is a must. He can do that in different ways, but he's a receiver first and foremost.
-
-
Amen. Colum about that from earlier this month:
BenFred: Even NL fundamentalists have to admit Pujols and Cardinals have made DH a hit
STLtoday.comSince the All-Star break, the Cardinals are leading MLB in OPS produced by designated hitter -
-
Drinkwitz said after the K-State game that Cook was the starter still, and the depth chart released today showed no changes. He went to Jack Abraham because Cook was getting roughed up and he thought maybe the backup could create a spark. Abraham didn't do anything to help his case, unfortunately. Drinkwitz said he did not consider playing Horn, the true freshman. If he felt he was ready then I'm guessing we would have seen him some Saturday. That suggests he doesn't think he's ready at this time, meaning Cook is the best option. Cook being the best option right now should not be too surprising, but it does stir up the memories of the three QB transfers Drinkwitz stuck out on this season.
-
I am a traditionalist, but I must say that I like the runner on second change in extras. Maybe start it in the 12th. The game where the Cards used a 5 man infield, maybe against the Reds, was exciting. Plus there are strategies used, like moving a runner to third, etc. Count me in on that one.
-
I hate it, personally.But I have no reason to believe it's going to stop.Players like it and want games to end sooner rather than later.Yes, including some of the same ones who whine about the pitch clock.TV wants games played within a window that is more or less set, and the rule helps that.If the league likes it, TV likes it and the players generally like it, it's gonna stick around.
-
-
Small sample size as you said but he's certainly been swinging. No strikeouts yet. Putting balls in play. I think his challenge right now is not being over eager, making sure he's swinging at good pitches and not just every pitch he can get his bat on. He's swung at half the pitches he's faced so far. Just needs to settle in a bit, which is common.
-
-
I said before the season started I think Drinkwitz's make-or-break season is year four not three, but it would be silly to ignore what factor fans play in this conversation. Their attendance and support or lack thereof can and will have to be considered by an athletics director who did not hire the coach. If the Tigers put the K-State mess behind them and move forward, calm will prevail. If it's a sign of what is to come then things could get pretty rough. When things get pretty rough at Mizzou, recent history suggests the attempted answer is change, not patience. I think it's too early to get too far down that road at this time.
-
What is the player's beef with the pitch clock? The PA reps on the committee all voted against it. Said they had provided suggested changes they'd like but were rejected. Have they said anything more? Does it have to do with the max two disengagements/throw overs and not the actual clock portion?
-
From what I've read and heard they had specific complaints and proposed tweaks to the rules that they were upset were not implemented by the league. They voted against because they felt like player feedback was not incorporated enough in the process. Specifically there were questions raised about how pitchers could work around the pitch clock, how base stealers could force pitchers to burn a throw over and then be more likely to steal after that, how the pitch clock could impact close games late when a pitcher could need more time, and more. One about shifts was how challenges raised about players potentially being in an illegal position could negate big plays. That's one of my big ones, the one I mentioned earlier. It could be similar to the offsides challenge in hockey, which is a nightmare especially when it results in a snapshot wiping away what should have been a good goal before the freeze frames got involved.
-
-
The rankings are still mostly just guesswork at this point.I don't pay too much attention to them until some more games are played.As for the second part, one of the benefits of the 12-team CFP expansion is that it should pour cold water on any idea of the Big Ten or the SEC starting competing playoff formats.That's good news for college football.They'll try to stack the playoff with their teams, not take their ball and start their own system.
-
-
Where is the answer least likely to come from an internal candidate? Probably at catcher, right away. The Cardinals have the National League's second-lowest OPS among catchers right now. Andrew Knizner's pitch-framing has been problematic. Ivan Herrera isn't quite ready. That feels like an important position that needs a more proven answer for 2023, even if it's a short-term one. Catcher has become a less important position across baseball over the years. I don't think it is for the Cardinals, at least not yet. Maybe when automated zones arrive but that won't be in 2023.
-
-
I'll take my annual stance of assuming the Cardinals are not going to break their trend of not wining whatever bidding war is waged for the offseason's top free agent. Boring, I know. But the Cardinals do their big deals -- Goldschmidt, Arenado -- in different ways, usually when they know what the price is and can plan around that on the front and back ends. A shorter term deal for a proven shortstop would make sense. I can't imagine why Turner would be interested in going short. He's the star of the class.
-
-
I think you all will really like the pitch clock.And fans, when asked, have cited games being too long as one of their biggest concerns.I've heard from plenty of fans who hate shifts, and I get their reasoning.I just don't like banning defensive creativity.Hitters can adjust more than they let on. We are seeing some do it more often -- but here comes the ban anyway.
-
-
-
-
-
-
Cardinals have an eight-game lead with a chance to really open it up against the Brewers if they take care of business. Pujols has a .640 slugging percentage this month. He starts against every lefty, can start against some manageable righties and will get pinch-hit chances against lefties off the bench, a weapon Marmol is not afraid to use early in a game. I think he's gonna be hitting a good amount here through the end. The Cardinals' lead and his performance encourages it. Marmol wants AP to get there, too.
-
-
-
Since you brought up the topic of LB and punt returns, I would like your perspective on the strategy for punt returns. From what I have seen, Drink has no confidence in the PR catching the football. When you do not catch the ball, you are susceptible to another 15 yards of roll. Basic football says you catch the ball on punt returns.
-
-
Hi Ben,
Waino has been a bit off in his last few starts. If Montgomery continues to pitch better than Waino down the stretch, do you think Oli will go with Montgomery to start Wild Card game 1 based on performance or opt for Waino based on seniority and postseason experience? Thanks. -
-
-
-