Join columnist Ben Frederickson for a live STL sports chat at 11 a.m. Tuesday

Join columnist Ben Frederickson for a live STL sports chat at 11 a.m. Tuesday

Ben Frederickson answers your Cardinals, Blues, St. Louis City, Mizzou and SLU questions in Tuesday's 11 a.m. live chat.

    Hey gang, hope your week is off to a strong start. It's a bummer last night's college football national championship was such a dud. No hard feelings toward TCU. I think Georgia would have made most teams look bad in that setting. Bulldogs got a lot better as the season went along, and it's crazy to think Mizzou gave UGA its best game of the season?! Anyway, I'm in the saddle for a few hours. Fire away.
    Thanks for your chat!
    I think the production/cost ratio the Cardinals will obtain fromAW will be vastly less than the pitcher they let go to New York. For an organization known for value, love of low hanging fruit and fiscal discipline it’s a head scratcher
    I'll push back on this premise a little bit. I don't think very many Cardinals fans would have liked the team telling Wainwright, who wanted to pitch another season and was good for all of last season except for the final month, that it did not have a place for him. If Wainwright was suiting up for the Braves this spring, or Skip Schumaker's Marlins, would that feel good? Doubt it. The bigger problem, from this vantage point, is assuming that bringing back Wainwright was the reason the Cardinals could not or did not go sign Carlos Rodon, or cannot/will not swing a trade for an impact starter before games start counting. They could have. They still can. I agree they need rotation help of the quality kind. That is true with or without Wainwright, and let's not forget he was second on the team in innings and quality starts last season. Compared to what some of the starters made this offseason, his one-year deal is not stopping the Cardinals from adding -- unless the Cardinals want it to. If so, that's not on Wainwright.
    OK, Mr. Optimist, Blues are at 44% on 538 for the postseason, up from 36% last Monday. Are you buying back in?
    No flip-flopping here, though the results since Ryan O'Reilly and Vladimir Tarasenko went down are not exactly discouraging Doug Armstrong from shopping both, are they? Brayden Schenn future captain? I could see it. I don't think Army slams the brakes on a selling lean for a fringe playoff team.
    What are you most looking forward to you regarding your time at WWU this weekend?
    It's a new location this season, at the Busch and Ballpark Village instead of the usual downtown hotel location. So, I'm really curious to see how Jim Hayes manages to sneak the writers a plate of snacks from the TV room. It's an annual tradition, The Cat sharing TV riches (and carbs) with the lowly print scribes. There could be new hurdles in his way this year, due to the venue change. He will come through.
    Ben, ever seen a more poorly designed defensive scheme as displayed last night by TCU? Three man pass rushes and a porous right side so open that you could have driven a truck through it. The BCS has to find a better way other than won/loss records to assure that the best two college teams meet in the championship. All the more reason Alabama should have made the final four. Yet, no reason for Georgia to pile on late in a game that was over at halftime. Thoughts?
    Hey, that defense got TCU there. A lot of teams had trouble with that funky 3-3-5 look. Georgia coach Kirby Smart made a point to praise his scout team after the confetti fell for preparing the Bulldogs so well to dismantle it, and they did. Smart is a special coach. If you give him that much time to prepare for something, he's got the chops and the roster talent to pass the test. TCU deserved to be there. It beat Michigan, earning its shot. Georgia would have thumped Michigan, too, I imagine, and anyone else it came up against last night. Alabama had its chance. As the playoff expands, and thankfully it is expanding, there will be even fewer what-ifs to consider. The bracket only cares about who the best team is on that day.
    Help me understand the urgency to extend Mikolas or Montgomery. Neither is elite and the “quantity over quality” rotation approach isn’t working in the post-season. Matz is your #3 going forward, why not take the $55m coming off the books this winter and go get two elite starters? Maybe one of them is even a short-term, high AAV deal (gasp!). Then, if this team is truly a draft & develop organization, how about developing some starters to populate the 4 and 5 spots in the rotation? This approach doesn’t raise payroll at all but does get away from paying four #3 starters, none of whom throw gas.
    The Cardinals like them both, for starters. Mikolas has been a great fit and has shown he can carry a big workload when healthy. He's been an All-Star here twice. Montgomery, to me, is more uncertain, but the Cardinals liked what they saw in him before the trade with the Yankees, and they liked what they saw from him in St. Louis even more. Neither is an ace and the Cardinals have an opening for number one they are ignoring until it's filled. Extending one or the other doesn't change that, for better or worse. And if the Cardinals are unwilling to pay the price in free agency or trade that it takes to acquire a true ace, then you better have a good batch of upper to middle rotation options. I agree the Cardinals should absolutely show more interest in those short-term, high-dollar deals for electric arms. Scherzer would have been great here. Verlander, too.
    Please don't give Miles Mikolas, who will be 35 this August, a new deal. Great guy, know he loves it here, appreciate his quirkiness, but what need does he fill? He's not a top-of-the-rotation pitcher and he's certainly not going to suddenly evolve into an ace. Re-signing him, to likely something north of his current $16.75m salary, moves him towards ace territory in that $20m range. Keep the friendship bracelets in the box this spring and resist overpaying for "good" players.
    The price for pitching is only going up, meaning the price for upper to mid-rotation level pitching is going to follow. I know everybody wants the Cardinals to add a sure-thing ace. So do I. But you still need a rotation beyond that, and extending a guy like Mikolas, bringing back a guy like Wainwright, are rotation-building moves. There isn't cheap pitching that is decent. Not in the rotation. Not for long, anyway.
    Will the third time be a charm? Reports just now that Carlos Correa and the Twins have agreed on a six-year, $200 million deal. This feels important: It's pending a physical. What a mess this saga has become.
    The Cardinals can’t be done…….right? Once again, they are fine and will compete for a playoff spot, but I feel like we almost have too much depth, too much of the same type of players. There has to be some trades to be made……
    Sure hope not. Their rotation needs an exclamation point. Too many question marks there at the moment. Trade should be the way. Miami is going to have to deal good pitching. The Marlins' addition of Cueto suggests that. Kind of crazy to realize Skip Schumaker is now Cueto's manager. No one would have predicted that during the Reds-Cards brawl of 2010.
    Not asking you to elaborate on a response, but something stinks down at Busch, right? Where's the spending post-Pujols Summer, post-Bamtech sale, post-saying they would spend?
    That will be a topic at this weekend's Winter Warm-Up, I'm sure. The answers, and how/if they change between the media room and the Q/A portion with fans, will be fascinating. The Cardinals did spend on Willson Contreras, their biggest offseason need. They have gone into stealth mode since. I'm not convinced it's a slumber, as some have assumed. It's worth remembering Mozeliak's recent home-run swings have come via trades (Goldschmidt, Arenado) not free-agent buys.
    Can you break down the cost on the open market for #1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 starters? ie #1 - $20M plus, #2 - $17.5M etc?
    The market reset again this offseason. Per Sportrac, here are the top-five annual salaries secured this offseason by free-agent starters. Future signings/extensions/trades will be based off this reset. 
    Justin Verlander (39 years old) is making $43 million per season over two seasons.
    Jacob deGrom (34 years old) is making $37 million per season over five seasons.
    Carlos Rodon (30 years old) is making $27 million per season over six seasons.
    Chris Bassitt (33 years old) is making $21 million per season over three seasons.
    Clayton Kershaw (34 years old) is making $20 million per season over one season.
    Down the list, for perspective, is Jose Quintana (33), who got $13 million per year for two seasons. I've said this before, but if the Cardinals don't add something to their rotation, coming up with that kind of deal for Quintana would have been doable and probably wise.
    Tough road for Mizzou Basketball, if they can win 3 road SEC games and 6 at home, then beat Iowa State I think they get in the NCAA. Mizzou football, my concern is the offensive line. They got a graduate out of the portal but he allowed 10 sacks and numerous hurries in his 4 years. I hope they can improve the line or we are looking at a 5 or 6 win season again.
    The Tigers are in great NCAA Tournament shape. They're No. 32 in the NET Rankings and their only two losses (at home to Kansas and on the road against Arkansas) are categorized as Quad 1 games. And they already have as many Quad 1 wins (two) as losses. Taking care of business at home against lower-NET teams is key, as the Tigers found a way to do against Vanderbilt. I was impressed by that win, because it was the first time in three games the Tigers did not start out the game seeing shots fall. They were cold. They fell behind. They figured it out. Good sign.
    Drinkwitz and his staff are targeting seasoning and experience in the offensive line portal pursuit. Good call. You can teach scheme and plays. You can't teach been-there-done-that, and guys like incoming Eastern Michigan transfer Marcellus Johnson have a lot of reps. It would be nice to see some SEC-type OL transfers, I agree. The Power 5 transfers Drinkwitz and his staff have landed have performed pretty well. The transfer-up guys have been more of a mixed bag. 
    "There isn't cheap pitching that is decent. Not in the rotation. Not for long, anyway"

    Yes, there was, Jose Quintana was there for the taking and he wanted to pitch here. $12.5 per years is a BARGAIN
    Yep, as I mentioned. If the Cardinals don't do anything else for this rotation, letting Quintana walk becomes more perplexing.
    Where did Quintana say he wanted to stay with the Cardinals?
    He was candid about it last season, as it wound down. He wanted to come back and had talked to Contreras about how much he enjoyed playing for the Cardinals.
    What gives on the Bally station financial troubles? How does that affect the Blues/Cardinals?That's a loss of big money,correct? What do you think happens? And,any word on filling the top announcing job? I've heard good things about Aaron Goldsmith.
    Too early to say on how it affects Cards/Blues, as they are just two of the teams that could be affected nationwide as the future of the regional sports networks are determined. In the long-term future, this probably plays out as individual leagues either owning their own streaming setup, or partnering with the big streamers (Disney, Apple, Amazon) for streaming deals. The cable-based system has gotten outdated, and it happened fast. How fast it gets there depends on all sorts of things. Contracts. Lawsuits. Lots of red tape will be sorted through.
    Correa has been playing just fine on this hurt leg no?
    Yep. That's if that is indeed the issue. There have been reports the hold-up has been due to differing opinions about the metal plate he had installed in his leg as a minor leaguer, something he referenced in September when a slide left him rattled. Considering the source on all of this stuff is always Scott Boras, it makes you wonder if maybe there's something else? I don't know, but I can see why the Twins would feel good about taking the discounted price for a reunion. They had him and know him and have to have the best information about his projected physical concerns, both real and overdramatized.
    Who do you think will replace Danny Mac on the Cards telecasts? Thanks
    Dan Caesar has been covering the process for us at the P-D. He's reported Costas, Buck and Amsinger are not options. That's the latest I've heard.
    When did Quintana become Steve Carlton? Until last year, he's been a below average pitcher since 2017. We have 5 starters + hudson, liberatore, pallante - they can find another starter at the deadline, like the last two years, if necessary.

    question - do you believe the rumors that they are quietly looking to trade? would it be for a bat or someone like Bieber (it would require a big prospect haul for him).
    I don't think anyone is claiming Quintana is a Hall of Famer. And I was just fine with letting him walk -- if you go out and improve the rotation with an addition that is better. So far, that has not happened. So I get the Quintana questions, especially considering the modest price he was acquired for by the Mets.
    It's not rumors they are vetting trades. It's fact. All front offices are vetting trades, tracking free agents. I think they need a high level starting pitcher more than another bat. Shane Bieber would be excellent. Pablo Lopez of the Marlins would do. I'm not convinced they are as comfortable with their current rotation as they are advertising. 
    Mizzou FB schedule next year is dauting - is the only way Drink survives if Sam Horn looks like a capable SEC QB?
    That's one way. But it's not the only way. New offensive coordinator. Returning starting quarterback in Brady Cook, who will have a repaired shoulder by then. Horn is going to get a ton of reps with Cook's surgery. If he doesn't make it clear he's the best option by the time Cook is cleared for full go, it could be Cook again next fall. And Eli has to start the best option to win, period. Because he's in must-win phase now.
    BenFred - I don't go to Winter Warm-Up but I was hoping you'd consider adding this question to your list for DeWitt: "What would you say to a fan who says "DeWitt doesn't have the passion to chase another title if it can't be done within his specific financials parameters"?"
    Mind if I tweak it? Because he has won championships, and others who have spent more can't always say the same. I'm more interested in when repeated recent results that should be viewed as not good enough (three straight wild-card round exits, no win in an NLCS game since 2014) start becoming a weight on the scale that suggests a change to the model. Not a scrapping of the model. An update of it. The repeated line from the Cardinals has been that they have their model and it will be tested. I'd argue the test has been happening, and that the Cardinals should not be happy with a repeated C-minus.
    Why wouldn't the Cardinals be in on Correa for 6/200 that the Twins are giving him? Seems like six years at that AAV wouldn't be a death knell in the current market, right?
    They've been pretty adamant that they're comfortable with Edman at shortstop. Only time that waivered some was when they were vetting potential trade for Murphy, one that could have cost them middle-infield talent and required a free-agent addition after the trade. That was how Swanson came into the potential picture for a bit.
    Did Mo learn something from the Ozuna trade? I feel like Goldy/Arenado trades were like tiny miracles. Change the way he values prospects? Timing? Luck?
Powered by Platform for Live Reporting, Events, and Social Engagement