That's a lot to ask. Guys with ability: Brett Hull (feel for the offensive game to go with quick shot release), Adam Oates (feel for the game, passing touch), Bernie Federko (ditto), Doug Gilmour (feared hunter of pucks), Al MacInnis (killer shot, worked to become all-around defender), Chris Pronger (defensive instincts, killer compete level), Brendan Shanahan (great shot), Vladimir Taraensko (great shot), Keith Tkachuk (total power forward package) . . . there were so many.
Underachiever? First-round pick Keith Osborne, picked ahead of Joe Sakic. Kid had a nice shot but zero heart.
Overachiever? Kelly Chase. Not big. Not fast. Not a big scorer. But he was willing to battle and built a heck of a career out of that. Imagine if he had Tkachuk's size and skill.